I write this as I look at the Trojan ad popping up on the side of this website. When I signed up for the ads on the site, I was told they would be somewhat related to what was written on the blogs. But I'll be honest, I'm not exactly sure how they jumped to condoms. Maybe I need to proofread my stuff better. But anyway...
Yesterday was the MLB trade deadline, and unlike Colonial Williamsburg, it did not disappoint. There were more guys flying around than in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Since I promised I would, I will now analyze all of the major moves of the past few days.
Trade 1:
Indians get Justin Masterson, Nick Hagadone, and Brian Price
Red Sox get Victor Martinez
Anyone who read yesterday's post will know that I like the term highway robbery. As in, when the Red Sox acquired Victor Martinez without surrendering any of their top 3 prospects, it was highway robbery. I know Hagadone has upside, but he is also coming off of major arm surgery. Color me skeptical about awarding him the honor of being an elite prospect. Masterson is a good arm, but I see him as having #3 upside. Which is not bad of course. I do not mean to say that the players that the Indians received are not good. They are all very promising arms. But I feel like for a catcher like Martinez, who has a line of .284/.368/.464 , you need to get more than just promising. I have this feeling that because Carlos Santana is ripping the hide off the ball, the Indians felt they could be lenient on what they got back. Not a very smart move in my opinion for the Indians, but a big win for the Sox, who acquire an impact bat without hurting the team they put out on the field.
Indians' Grade: B-
Red Sox Grade: A-
Trade 2:
Phillies get Cliff Lee and Ben Francisco
Indians get Jason Knapp, Lou Marson, Jason Donald, and Carlos Carrasco
The rich get richer. The defending champs acquire a legit #1 starter as well as a good 4th outfielder. As we all know, the Phils were pining for Roy Halladay. But they probably made the better deal. They did not surrender Drabek, Taylor, or Brown (their top three prospects), and managed to acquire a fantastic pitcher. I personally think that this entire ordeal has over hyped Drabek, Taylor, and Brown (which kind of sounds like an old law firm), but if the league values them so highly, then so be it. I believe that the Indians could have acquired more in this trade. Carrasco is not as special as people say. He is inconsistent, and probably would be better served as a power bulpen arm. Donald and Marson are fringe starters at the pro level. Knapp is probably the most intriguing arm. I like his mechanics and poise, and although I don't think that the Halladay comparison that has been thrown around is off base, I think Knapp stand to become the best prospect received in the deal.
Indians Grade: C+
Phillies Grade: A
Trade 3:
White Sox get Jake Peavy
Padres get Aaron Poreda, Clayton Richard, Dexter Carter, and Adam Russell
Ken Williams makes a strange move. First off, he seems to not be sure exactly what he's trying to do. Peavy is locked up until 2013, and although he is expensive, his contract isn't terrible. But half of his efforts seem to be dedicated at retooling with youth, while the other half is spent on dealing youth for established talent. But if Williams is going to pull the trigger on a deal which sends some of his best young arms, why not get a starter who is healthy and could contribute immediately. Does he want to win this year? Or is he building for the future? Or is he trying to do both, which never works.
The Padres get a very good haul in this deal. Some speculate that Poreda would be a better bulpen arm, but I think he can be a good starter, especially in Petco. Russell and Carter are two very good arms, with Carter quietly leading the Minors in K's. Richard has been batted around this year, but his main problem is the gopher ball, which should be slightly fixed at Petco. Could they have gotten better? Maybe, but with Peavy's injury and the Friars going no where this season, the move makes sense.
Sox Grade: B
Padres' Grade: B+
Trade 4:
Giants get Freddy Sanchez
Pirates get Tim Alderson
I understand the trade for both sides. The Giants feel pressure to make the playoffs, and Sanchez was not a part of the Pirate's long term plans. I'm actually surprised the Pirates acquired a top line prospect. Generally, the Pirates have been taking quantity over quality. Despite dealing better players such as Mclouth and Bay, I would wager that Alderson becomes the best player they acquired. People have fallen down on Alderson, but I like his deceptive delivery (something I think we as a community undervalue). I do, however, have some qualms with getting Sanchez. I know that the Giants had a black hole at 2nd, but they are last in the league in OBP, yet acquire a guy with only a .334 OBP. I don't know, I think they could've done a bit better.
Pirates Grade: B+
Giants Grade: B-
Trade 5:
Reds get Scott Rolen
Blue Jays get Edwin Encarnacion, Josh Roenicke, and Zack Stewart
I understand that Rolen is a major defensive upgrade to Encarnacion, but he is also 8 years older. It's a great trade for the Jays, but I don't really get the Reds' motivation. They're not winning this year, and it's not like they have any good guys at 3rd in their system. Kind of a puzzling move for the Reds, whose problem isn't infield defense, but keeping the ball in the ballpark. Encarnacion might have to move to DH or 1st eventually, but until then, I'll take him over Rolen anyday.
Jays Grade: B+
Reds Grade: C
Trade 6:
Dodgers get George Sherrill
Orioles get Josh Bell and Steve Johnson
Torre gets another bulpen arm to tire out and destroy. Seriously though, I like the trade for the Dodgers. I know people are intrigued by Bell's power potential, but I think we sometimes tend to overvalue prospects who, like Bell, are thrust into the spotlight when traded. I think his upside is as a marginal starter in this league. Johnson looks like a good innings eater, so I think the Orioles get an okay haul in this, especially since it gives the 25 year old Jim Johnson the opportunity to close, but I think they could've gotten more.
Dodgers Grade: B
Orioles Grade: C+
Trade 7:
Red Sox get Corey Kotchman
Braves get Adam Laroche
Who says you can't go home? Laroche, who is a fairly underrated player in this league, goes from a bench role in Boston to a starting gig in Atlanta, where he began his career. I'm slightly upset about this trade, since I have always liked Kotchman, and felt that while he would never become a star, he could develop into a Sean Casey type player. I guess the Sox wanted to get a better defensive guy off the bench, but I feel like they don't really need Kotch. I would've liked it if they could've maybe instead dealt Laroche for some bulpen depth. But I've learned to never question Epstein. He is a genius.
Sox Grade: B-
Braves' Grade: B
Trade 8:
Fishies get Nick Johnson
Nats AAA get Aaron Thompson
THE EMILIO BONAFACIO ERA IS OVER. It's about time. The guy cannot hit a lick, and you can't steal 1st. He is a good utility guy, and could develop into a Chone Figgons lite (very lite). I don't get the Nats' rationale. Thompson is a 4th starter, and we know that only a year after being drafted. Johnson, while never healthy in the past, has put up very solid numbers. I feel like a team such as the Mets would've given more for Johnson, who is an above average fielder. I guess that's just Washington being Washington. Good for the Marlins for acquiring someone who could become a dark horse candidate for biggest impact on a contender.
Marlins' Grade: B+
Nats' Grade: C-
Trade 9:
Tigers get Jarrod Washburn
Mariners get Luke French and and Mauricio Robles
This one is kind of funny to me. The M's were asking for Austin Jackson or Jesús Montero for Washburn from the Yankees, yet they eventually settle on this package? That's like going for the prettiest girl in the bar all night, then leaving with the fat chick who brought her cat with her. Neither French nor Robles has all that high of a ceiling, and while Washburn's ERA is an aberration, there is always a need for starters. The Mariners could have gotten more for Washburn.
M's Grade: B-
Tigers Grade: B
Trade 10:
Twins get Orlando Cabrera
A's get Tyler Ladendorf
I don't get it. Didn't the A's draft a toolsy shortstop in this year's draft (Grant Green)? I know that Brad Pitt, er, I mean, Billy Beane likes these kinds of guys (low cost, high upside, young, foreign), but why not get someone who is even in the Twins' top 10 prospects (according to BA)? O cab (as only I call him) isn't in the A's long term plans I guess, so the deal makes sense to an extent. I guess the Twins are trying to make a push? They always seem to surprise everyone by being good when they shouldn't be. Twins win in this one.
Twins Grade: B-
A's Grade: C